50 Years as a Rabbi: Looking Back, Looking Forward

:

Ecclesiastes, (chapter 3) reminds us; “There is a time for every purpose under heaven.”

 When I turned 77 last year, it dawned on me with stark clarity that it was time to ring down the curtain on my tenure as Spiritual Leader of Bat Yam Temple of the Islands in Sanibel, Florida, and retire. 

I will always, of course, be a rabbi, and I will await in wonder to see what new plans the Eternal One has in store for me.

When I announced I would retire the first time in 2012 from my position as Senior Rabbi of Congregation Beth Israel in West Hartford, Connecticut, people asked, “What will you do now?”  I honestly answered, “I am not sure. “I’ll read more, write more and beyond that, we’ll see.”

I could never have imagined the blessings the “we’ll see” had in store for me these past 12 Years: Serving as President of the World Union for Progressive Judaism,  which enabled me to visit more than 65 communities on five continents teaching about and advocating for progressive Jewish values, serving as guest Rabbi in Milan and Florence, Italy, spending significant parts of five years teaching and preaching in Germany, and then serving for six years as Rabbi of Bat Yam Temple of the Islands. 

Among the highlights of our years in Germany have been the invitations to teach with Vickie about the Shoah in German schools, speak in the synagogue and in churches and at Kristallnacht commemorations in Leipzig Germany, the city where my father, Leo Fuchs, of blessed memory grew up and was arrested and imprisoned on November 9, 1938.

Our tradition teaches that King Solomon wrote three biblical books: Song of Songs, a book of love poetry when he was a young man, Proverbs a book of wisdom in middle age, and Ecclesiastes, with its sober look at life as an older man.

Although I cannot claim Solomon’s wisdom, I have been blessed to find true love as a young man, and the loving marriage I have shared with Vickie for all the 50 years of my career years has sustained me through the many joys and the few disappointments of my career.

I have tried my best to share what wisdom I have gained in my sermons, lectures and in the college and seminary teaching I have been invited to do over the years and in the seven books I have written. 

Upon ordination in 1974, I became the first-full time Rabbi of Temple Isaiah, in Columbia Maryland, a synagogue launched by my beloved mentor, Rabbi Richard S. Sternberger, z’l, UAHC Mid-Atlantic Regional Director.

Beginning in 1986 I became Senior Rabbi at Congregation Ohabai Sholom, known as The Temple, in Nashville, Tennessee. I will always be grateful that the congregation funded my graduate studies at Vanderbilt Divinity School which culminated when I earned a DMin. in biblical Interpretation in 1992.

In 1997, I became Senior Rabbi at Congregation Beth Israel until I became Rabbi Emeritus in 2012.

Now that I am older, I look back on my 50-year rabbinical career and reach the important conclusion Ecclesiastes teaches (chapter 1):

 “Vanity of vanities, everything is vanity.” 

How true I find those words today.

What is truly important to me now is not recognition or material rewards. I do not deny that I have striven for and enjoyed a measure of those things, but the joy does not last that long and looking back, they matter very little. 

What I shall always cherish and what will always matter are the times when something I did, wrote, or said made a real difference in someone’s life. It was in those moments or when someone reminded me of them, that I truly felt God’s pleasure. Participating in our son, Leo’s ordination in Los Angeles last May is a wonderful retirement present and a memory I shall always cherish.

As they did back in 2012, people ask me, “What will you do now?”

For the time being I am proud to become Bat Yam’s Rabbi Emeritus.

In addition, I would add, “I’ll read more, write more, and beyond that, we’ll see.”

.

…It’s Good to Be Back Home

Although we don’t live on a farm, the late John Denver’s classic, Back Home Again, beautifully captures my feelings, when after 16 days in Tampa, we arrived back home in Sanibel.

We can’t say enough good things about the Moffitt Cancer Center, where Vickie, who never smoked, underwent lung cancer surgery, or the staff at the Marriott Moffitt Residence Inn where we stayed.

Over the course of my life I have had six highly skilled surgeons who have operated on me, but none spent nearly the amount of time empathetically responding to concerns and answering questions as Dr. Samuel Freyaldenhoven did with Vickie and me

The new McKinley Avenue Campus of the Moffitt Center with spacious private rooms for every patient is the most beautiful hospital I have ever seen, but the six days we spent there were more than enough. We stayed in Tampa so that Vickie would still be “in town” for her follow up tests and appointment with “Dr. Frey.”

Our children, Leo, Sarah and Ben, along with their wonderful spouses, Liz, Clive and Kristin, have been so wonderfully comforting and supportive. Our Bat Yam congregational community, tennis-playing friends and our Farm Trail neighbors have all warmed our hearts with their genuine caring and concern.

Thank you FaceBook!

We are well aware of Facebooks flaws. Hacking and countless ads are a pain. But we are so very grateful that FB has enabled us to receive wonderfully encouraging messages of support from around the world and from every period in our lives. They mean so much to both of us.

Nevertheless, Vickie still deals with very significant pain. Though her doctors say it will abate soon, soon cannot come soon enough. I am in awe of the courage and strength with which Vickie has coped with all of it. Taking care of her, and watching her get better is a great privilege for me.

John Denver captures my feelings better than I can express them:

It’s the sweetest thing I know of

Just spending time with you

It’s the little things that make a house a home.

Like a fire softly burning

The light in your eyes, it makes me warm.

Yes, without a doubt, it’s good to be back home again.

Happy Birthday, My Love

I fell for Vickie the first time I laid eyes on her in the same WHAMO way that Michael Corleone fell for Apollonia in Godfather I. I love her even more today.

Below: Vickie and I when we met

My prayer for Vickie’s 75th birthday is that her trip around the sun that begins today will be much easier than the last.

She fought off lymphoma with the help of wonderful medical teams in both Fort Myers and the Moffitt Cancer Center here in Tampa. When she “rang the bell” to signify the successful completion of her six chemo treatments we thought we were home free.

Below: Vickie and I after she rang the bell at Moffitt Cancer Center one year ago!

The diagnosis of lung cancer that followed not long thereafter –especially for a person who never smoked –came as a great shock.

But Vickie has met that challenge head on!

On December 29 she underwent major surgery to remove the cancerous portion –about 1/3 of the total– of her left lung. The pain she continues to endure brings tears to my heart. Now we wait for test results which could come within days or a couple of weeks. They will determine what we must do next.

Regardless, I am confident that Vickie will beat this!

Despite the tribulations of this past year, which include being forced out of our home for seven months due to the devastation of Hurricane Ian, there have been moments of great joy to savor:

  • The Bar Mitzvah services of our grandsons Micah and Jeremy
  • The ordination — after five long years of study — of our son Leo
  • The celebration of my formal retirement from and designation as Rabbi Emeritus of Bat Yam Temple of the islands
  • The joy of officiating at the installation ceremony of our dear friend Rabbi Julia Margolis as Spiritual Leader of the Hebrew Congregation of St. Thomas in the Virgin Islands
  • Serving as Rabbi on a Chanukah cruise to the Bahamas
  • The joy we both derive from playing tennis in Sanibel
  • Our 49th wedding anniversary
  • The amazing support of so many people for Vickie and me that gives us both strength

As we each ponder our many blessings say with the Psalmist (23:5):

כוסי רויה

My cup runneth over!

IMay God grant her a complete and speedy recovery! May she soon be pain free! And may we enjoy many more of her birthdays together!

Below: Vickie today.. Happy Birthday, my love!

Home from the Hospital

Well, not really home! We will stay in Tampa at a Residence Inn for several days to give Vickie further time to recover from her lung cancer surgery.

We cannot say enough good things about the care she is receiving through the Moffitt Cancer Center. The brand new McKinley Avenue hospital is beautiful, and the staff members— from the parking attendants to the top surgeons and everyone in between — have been skillful, patient and extremely kind.

We must still wait for pathology test results before mapping next steps, but we shall take it one day at a time. I am happy, meanwhile, to be her Errand Boy as she is not yet allowed to shop.

Vickie drawing strength from FT with our children and grandchildren.

The words of Psalm 23, one of the first prayers I learned as a young child reverberate in my head and strengthen me

גם כי אלך בגיא צלמות

לא אירא רע כי אתה עמדי…

“Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death,

I will fear no evil, for Thou art with me…“

I also draw great strength from Vickie herself! I am in awe of her courage and resolve. I still envision her as she rang the bell in triumph after her last (of six) chemo treatments for lymphoma one year ago tomorrow. Her once beautiful straight hair had been replaced by an attractive wig.

Now her hair is back — curly, thick— and stronger than ever. To me that strong, thick, curly head of hair symbolizes her great strength, the strength that I trust will carry her through whatever may lie ahead.

We also are beyond grateful for the many messages of encouragement and support that people from all walks of our lives and from all corners of the world are sending. We are grateful for each and every one!

Right now, we are physically and emotionally exhausted, but we are glad to be out of the hospital, eager to rest up tonight and continue our cancer journey with renewed vigor tomorrow.

New Year, New Hope

2023 began with Vickie and me exiled from our home because of Hurricane Ian and she undergoing treatment for Stage Three Non- Hodgkin’s Lymphoma.

When Vickie “rang the bell” after completing six grueling rounds of chemo therapy, and her subsequent PET scan came back clean, we thought we were home free.

Alas, we were not.

When a later test showed “some unusual activity ” in her lungs, it felt like a mule kick to the gut. The right lung abnormality was “just” pneumonia, but the left lung was pneumonia … and cancer.

And so, 2024 begins with us in the brand new McKinley Avenue Hospital of the Moffitt Cancer Center where Vickie underwent major surgery for the type of lung cancer non-smokers like she is sometimes suffer. They tell us her two cancers are unrelated to one another.

It has not been an easy time!

And yet… we are full of hope. Our wonderful surgeon, Dr. Samuel Freyaldenhoven is confident we will beat this, and his confidence inspires us both. In the 18 months that Moffitt has been “our second home” everyone here — the parking attendants, the housekeepers, the tech staff, the nurses, and the top cancer doctors who have treated Vickie — have been caring and kind.

Our three children and their wonderful spouses have been with us through daily contact, advice and encouragement. We have been very blessed!

We are still waiting for test results, and Vickie having gone through chemo and major surgery has been to hell and back. Still, I can’t stifle the feeling that 2024 — despite its beginning in pain and anxiety— will evolve into a wonderful year.

This Time the Candles Will Burn Down

This Shabbat finds me alone in Sanibel. Vickie is in San Francisco looking after her wonderful 102-year-old mother. If I must be without her on Shabbat, I can think of no better reason. There is no service to attend…certainly not one to rush to be there in time to conduct. I am retired.

I prepared a simple Shabbat meal for myself, tasty if I may say so, but nothing close to the feasts that Vickie prepares week in and week out. Our meal begins with the traditional blessings over the candles the wine and the challah.  When we finish, and it is time to go to synagogue, we blow the candles out so as not to risk a fire burning down our house, but not in step with our religious tradition.

But this week there is no need to blow the candles out. This week, although I am alone, I find company in the beauty of the Venetian glass candle sticks Vickie bought before we were married and in the beauty of the softly dancing flame of the tapers.

When I conducted Erev Shabbat (Friday evening) services) I sometimes resented having to rush through our Shabbat meal and get to the synagogue well ahead of service time to be sure that l was ready for worship. I used to ask myself each week, “Why, after 50 years of doing this, do I still get nervous before every service I conduct? I took comfort in telling myself it was because I wanted to give my very best to whoever came – whether there were few or many – to worship.

Tonight, I have nothing to be nervous about. I can read a book, drink a leisurely cup of Chamomile tea, go to bed early and not be all keyed up like I am when I come home from conducting services and asking myself inwardly whether my efforts were successful or not. Did the time and preparation I put into the service pay off in a meaningful experience for those who were there?

Lately I ask myself the “Did I make a difference” question in the macro sense after leading worship for more than fifty years, in my student pulpit in Arkansas, in Columbia, Maryland, in Nashville, in West Hartford in my travels around the World with the World Union for Progressive Judaism, in my subsequent work in Milan, Florence and various parts of Germany, and for the last six years here in Sanibel. I am grateful for the appreciation tributes I have received from each of the congregations I have served. They comfort me, but they don’t quench the feeling that maybe there is more I can do.

One thing I have learned: to take satisfaction in the effort I put forth. And now …I am happy I can really rest on Shabbat without pressure, without nervousness, but part of me wishes I was still standing before a group of worshippers sharing the fruit of my many years of study. One of my favorite sayings is,” We have all been expelled from the Garden of Eden.”  Life is never perfect. 

As Kohelet (Ecclesiastes 3:1) teaches us, “There is a time for everything.” For me this is the time to enjoy…having the time to watch the Shabbat candles burn all the way down.

He Cared

What is the legacy you want to leave behind?

In two words, that is my answer, “He cared.”

In thousands of interactions as a rabbi, over the last 50 years, I cannot say I have always been right. I know that I have not. But I am proud to say, “I never phoned it in.” I cared deeply about the people with whom I dealt, the subjects I have tackled, the projects I have undertaken, and the speeches and sermons I have delivered.

I hope too I will be remembered for my role bringing the first female Cantor and first female rabbi to Columbia, Maryland, the first female rabbi to Nashville, Tennessee, and the first female Cantor to West Hartford, Connecticut. And most of all … I hope people will remember my role in bringing the first lesbian rabbi to West Hartford and that there were those back in 1999 who wanted my head on a platter for doing so.

The general acceptance of LGBTQ individuals as clergy in non-Orthodox Jewish life today is, thankfully, a given. It was unheard of when I was ordained in 1974, and it was uneasy in my congregation in 1999. We have come a long way.

A year ago, our movement celebrated the 50th anniversary of the ordination of Sally Priesand as our first woman rabbi. Now women outnumber men among those entering the rabbinate. The infusion of women rabbis has brought about a mind-boggling sea change in our movement’s sensitivity and inclusivity.

I would like people to remember my small role in furthering that process. I would like people to know that I did those things to fulfill God’s covenantal charge to Abraham to do, צדקה ומשפט׳ “what is right and just.” (Genesis 18:19)

No, if I am honest, I cannot say I was always “right.” But I can honestly say I always cared.

Oh, I hate Cold Weather

How do you feel about cold weather?

After four years at Hamilton College in upstate NY, I hate the cold. Ever since the time in February when our hockey team, for which I logged more bench time than ice time, played MIT in Boston, outdoors and at night, I have been cold.

Six years ago we moved to Sanibel, Florida when I became Rabbi of Bat Yam Temple of the Islands. This past fall Hurricane Ian devastated our home, our synagogue and the whole island. Recovery is slow. But we are coming back!

Now that I have retired from my position, we shall still live in Sanibel. We love the people, we love the weather, we love our home, and we love the fact that wearing just shorts and a tee shirt, we can comfortably p,any tennis outdoors in February.

As I have often written, “We have all been expelled from the Garden of Eden.” I.e, nobody has it perfect. That said I will trade the downside of living on Sanibel for not being cold any day of the week. I hate to be cold.

Calling it a Career

Rabbi Stephen Lewis Fuchs

Ecclesiastes, (chapter 2) reminds us there is a time for every purpose under heaven. When I turned 77  a few weeks ago, it dawned on me with stark clarity that it was time to ring down the curtain on my  tenure as Spiritual Leader of Bat Yam Temple of the Islands.

It has been my great privilege the past six years to serve this remarkable congregation. I will always, of course, be a rabbi, and I will await in wonder to see  what new plans the Eternal One has in store for me.

When I retired the first time in 2012 from my position as Senior Rabbi of Congregation Beth Israel in West Hartford, Connecticut, people asked what are your plans?  I honestly answered, “read more, write more and beyond that, we’ll see.”

I could never have imagined the blessings the “we’ll see” had in store for me these past 11 Years: Serving as President of the World Union for Progressive Judaism, a role in which I visited more than 65 communities on five continents teaching about and advocating for progressive Jewish values, serving as guest Rabbi in Milan and Florence, Italy, spending significant parts of five years teaching and preaching in Germany, and then serving for six years at Bat Yam Temple of the Islands.

Our tradition teaches (although most scholars doubt this is historically true) that King Solomon wrote three biblical books: Song of Songs, a book of love poetry when he was a young man, Proverbs a book of wisdom in middle age, and Ecclesiastes, with its sober look at life as an older man.

Although I hardly approach Solomon’s wisdom, I have been blessed to find true love as a young man, and the loving marriage I  have shared with Vickie for nearly 49 years has sustained me through the many joys and the few disappointments of my career.

I have tried my best to share what wisdom I have gained in my sermons and lectures over the years and in the seven books I have written. Now that I am older, I look back on my 50-year rabbinical career and reach  the important conclusion Ecclesiastes teaches (chapter 1):

 “Vanity of vanities, everything is vanity.” 

How true I find those words today.

What is truly important is not recognition or material rewards. I do not deny that I have striven for and enjoyed a measure of those things, but the joy does not last that long and looking back, they matter very little. 

What I shall always cherish and what will always matter are the times when something I did or said made a real difference in someone’s life. It was in those moments or when someone reminded me of them, that I truly felt God’s pleasure.

As they did back in 2012, people are starting to ask me, “What will you do now?”

The truth is I have not given it much thought yet.  For the time being I am proud to become Bat Yam’s Rabbi Emeritus.

In addition, I will add, “I’ll read more, write more, and beyond that, we’ll see.”

.

Barbara Brill, January 31, 2023

When I think of Barbara Brill, these words of a famous Nat “King” Cole song play in my mind: “Unforgettable, that’s what you are.”

Life dealt Barbara Brill a difficult hand, but she never let cerebral palsy get in her way.

She moved, oh so slowly, but her mind was lightning quick. She earned a Masters in speech therapy and helped many people overcome their verbal challenges.

One of my favorite Midrashim teaches that since the time God finished the work of creation, the Eternal One has been very busy arranging marriages.  To me there is no better proof of that tradition than Mike and Barbara Brill.  They were truly meant for each other.  They met at Camp Green Tot, a camp for physically challenged kids when they were nine years old.  Barb remembers that Mike liked another girl, but he gave Barb candy just to make the other girl jealous.   “Well one thing led to another,” as Barb put it, and they became a couple.

They married on January 24, 1960 and blessed each other’s life as husband and wife for nearly 51 years

They worked as a team whose handicaps and strengths coordinated like meshing gears.  Mike moved fast but spoke with difficulty.  Barbara moved slowly but spoke perfectly.

On December 8, 1979, Barbara mounted the bima of Temple Isaiah and became an adult Bat Mitzvah.  She read the story of Jacob’s struggle with God to become Yisrael – one who struggles with God – and how he walked with a limp ever after.  She taught the congregation a great deal that day about how her life was a living embodiment of that struggle.

Barb was part of Temple Isaiah’s first ever adult Bat Mitzvah class.  For a whole year the group studied together.  Then, each chose the portion of the Torah that meant the most to her. On the Shabbat that portion was read, the other members of the class divided up the morning prayers, and the person whose portion fell on that week read from the scroll and taught the congregation the meaning of the portion. Barb identified with Jacob because she herself walked only with the aid of crutches attached to her hands. “I chose this portion,” Barb said, “ because I understand what it is like having to walk through life with a limp.”

And yet, like Jacob prevailed in his struggle, Barb met and prevailed over the many challenges she faced in her life.

Very rarely did Barbara and Mike miss services at Temple Isaiah, and then only if one of them was not well.  I remember standing outside the Meeting House in Oakland Mills one Friday night when there was a serious snowstorm, wondering if anyone else would show up. But the Brills were there. I can still see Barb gingerly and carefully placing her crutches on the ice as I held my breath with each step she took.

Barbara and Mike Brill’s fondest wish was that they could become parents.  “There is no way,” I thought, “that they could handle a child.” But they knew differently.  They tried tirelessly to adopt for ten years, but they had no success.  You would think most people would give up after that amount of time, but not Barbara and Mike Brill.

One day a miracle occurred. 

They visited the Gallagher Center where they tried to help kids.  A little girl came over and sat in Barb’s lap.  She spent time living with the Brills and eventually they adopted her.  She was wild and hard to control, but Barb and Mike gave her abundant love, structure and discipline.  In her new home Ellen thrived and made enormous progress thanks to her loving and devoted parents.

Five years later, Ellen tragically died when she was run over by a car. Barb and Mike’s sadness was impossible to describe.

But Barb and Mike did not give up.

The adopted a son, Kevin, several years later because they had so much love to give and so much to teach a young boy about life’s challenges.

When Mike died in 2010, I feared Barb might fall apart. I need not have worried. Just as she had met and overcome every other challenge life threw onto her path, Barbed limped forward with courage and determination. By living until age 86, she defied all the actuarial predictions of life spans for those afflicted with cerebral palsy.

Barb, I hope and trust you were able to hear the last phone message I left for you before Shabbat last Friday:

“You have been an enormous inspiration on my life. Whenever, I feel frustrated by the little challenges in my own life, I think of all that you have overcome.”

Had I thought of it, I would have added, “Unforgettable, that’s what you are!”

January 31, 2023

When I think of Barbara Brill, these words of a famous Nat “King” Cole song play in my mind: “Unforgettable, that’s what you are.”

Life dealt Barbara Brill a difficult hand, but she never let cerebral palsy get in her way.

She moved, oh so slowly, but her mind was lightning quick. She earned a Masters in speech therapy and helped many people overcome their verbal challenges.

One of my favorite Midrashim teaches that since the time God finished the work of creation, the Eternal One has been very busy arranging marriages.  To me there is no better proof of that tradition than Mike and Barbara Brill.  They were truly meant for each other.  They met at Camp Green Tot, a camp for physically challenged kids when they were nine years old.  Barb remembers that Mike liked another girl, but he gave Barb candy just to make the other girl jealous.   “Well one thing led to another,” as Barb put it, and they became a couple.

They married on January 24, 1960 and blessed each other’s life as husband and wife for nearly 51 years.  They worked as a team whose handicaps and strengths coordinated like meshing gears.  Mike moved fast but spoke with difficulty.  Barbara moved slowly but spoke perfectly.

On December 8, 1979, Barbara mounted the bima of Temple Isaiah and became an adult Bat Mitzvah.  She read the story of Jacob’s struggle with God to become Yisrael – one who struggles with God – and how he walked with a limp ever after.  She taught the congregation a great deal that day about how her life was a living embodiment of that struggle.

Barb was part of Temple Isaiah’s first ever adult Bat Mitzvah class.  For a whole year the group studied together.  Then, each chose the portion of the Torah that meant the most to her. On the Shabbat that portion was read, the other members of the class divided up the morning prayers, and the person whose portion fell on that week read from the scroll and taught the congregation the meaning of the portion. Barb identified with Jacob because she herself walked only with the aid of crutches attached to her hands. “I chose this portion,” Barb said, “ because I understand what it is like having to walk through life with a limp.”

And yet, like Jacob prevailed in his struggle, Barb met and prevailed over the many challenges she faced in her life.

Very rarely did Barbara and Mike miss services at Temple Isaiah, and then only if one of them was not well.  I remember standing outside the Meeting House in Oakland Mills one Friday night when there was a serious snowstorm, wondering if anyone else would show up. But the Brills were there. I can still see Barb gingerly and carefully placing her crutches on the ice as I held my breath with each step she took.

Barbara and Mike Brill’s fondest wish was that they could become parents.  “There is no way,” I thought, “that they could handle a child.” But they knew differently.  They tried tirelessly to adopt for ten years, but they had no success.  You would think most people would give up after that amount of time, but not Barbara and Mike Brill.

One day a miracle occurred.  They visited the Gallagher Center where they tried to help kids.  A little girl came over and sat in Barb’s lap.  She spent time living with the Brills and eventually they adopted her.  She was wild and hard to control, but Barb and Mike gave her abundant love, structure and discipline.  In her new home Ellen thrived and made enormous progress thanks to her loving and devoted parents.

Five years later, Ellen tragically died when she was run over by a car. Barb and Mike’s sadness was impossible to describe.

But Barb and Mike did not give up. The adopted a son, Kevin, several years later because they had so much love to give and so much to teach a young boy about life’s challenges.

When Mike died in 2010, I feared Barb might fall apart. I need not have worried. Just as she had met and overcome every other challenge life threw onto her path, Barbed limped forward with courage and determination. By living until age 86, she defied all the actuarial predictions of life spans for those afflicted with cerebral palsy.

Barb, I hope and trust you were able to hear the last phone message I left for you before Shabbat last Friday:

“You have been an enormous inspiration on my life. Whenever, I feel frustrated by the little challenges in my own life, I think of all that you have overcome.”

Had I thought of it, I would have added, “Unforgettable, that’s what you are!”